Monday, October 8, 2018

English 101 - Rhetorical Analysis Essay


Kathleen Kagan
Britt – English 101
Writing Project 2
30 September 2018
Sojourner Truth – Ain’t I a Woman
            “Ain’t I a Woman” was a speech given by a former slave known as Sojourner Truth at the Women’s Convention in Akron, Ohio, in 1851.  In it, Sojourner Truth describes the common problems of women’s rights, especially those of black women following state-led emancipation (Ohio in 1802, and New York in 1827), but preceding federal emancipation (in 1865).  She details an encounter with an unknown man, assumed to be one of the ministers speaking at the convention, who describes the lengths he will go to for a white woman, which is a luxury never afforded to Truth herself.  She further discusses that intellect has nothing to do with women’s or black people’s rights, and that women deserve to have equal rights to men, despite being told otherwise.
Sojourner Truth was born a slave, known then as Isabella Bomfree, in Hurley, New York in 1797.  She escaped slavery with her infant daughter a year before slavery was outlawed in New York State (in 1827) and was granted her freedom when the abolitionist family who took her in bought her for twenty dollars.  She then began working for a minister, delivering charismatic speeches, which led her to meet abolitionists, women’s right activists, and prohibition (also known as “temperance”) activists. Though she never learned to read or write, she was able to dictate her life story to a writer, named Olive Gilbert, and was able to live off of the sales of her biography, which also drew her national acclaim. In 1851, when the speech was given, slavery was still a reality for many black people, especially in the south.  Though New York State, where Truth resided, had outlawed slavery in 1827, slavery wouldn’t be outlawed nationally until 1865, over a decade after Truth delivered her impassioned speech to the women’s convention in Ohio. 
“Ain’t I a Woman,” was the battle cry of her era, highlighting “the racial and gender inequality by reminding listeners of her combined strength and female status.” (Michals) The short speech detailed the struggles of a black woman, a newly freed slave, in America, who was not granted the same rights or representation as white women.  She outlined the struggles and hardships that black women had to overcome to be seen and heard in an area that only recently had freed them from enslavement.  Stating, “I have borne thirteen children, and seen most all sold off to slavery, and when I cried out with my mother's grief, none but Jesus heard me!” Truth reiterates a common struggle of enslaved women throughout America, that of bearing children who were all enslaved and sold.  Once freed, Truth became the first black woman to win a lawsuit in the United States, having successfully sued for the return of one of her children (Peter) that was illegally sold into slavery in Alabama, and later against a newspaper that defamed her. (Library of Congress)
In Truth’s world, women were not able to vote equally, or have equal representation under the law.  She lived in a world where men talked down to women and denied them due process because of their “delicate” nature.  This was doubly true for black women, who were often ignored or denigrated based on the color of their skin.  The real purpose of her speech was to highlight the inequality between men and women.  Though she was speaking as a black woman, and though her speech begins with a description of how black women were treated differently than white women, ultimately the audience was full of women, being a women’s convention, and her words were directed at the women in the crowd. 
            Though her “Ain’t I a Woman” speech was short, it had a large impact on listeners.  The speech was delivered at a women’s convention where a large part of the audience was women, and likely, white women, to admonish the white male attitude that women are feeble and in need of direct assistance, while black women were largely ignored.  Truth spoke after a series of ministers, who all touted that women were already treated well, and that they didn’t need equality.  While her speech primarily focused on the disparities between women and men, it also highlighted the difference between white and black women in the same era.  It is said that the original recording of her speech (done by Frances Gage in 1863) was done in a southern dialect, though Truth was neither from the south nor did she have a southern accent. (Sojourner Truth Memorial Committee)
“That man over there says that women need to be helped into carriages, and lifted over ditches, and to have the best place everywhere. Nobody ever helps me into carriages, or over mud-puddles, or gives me any best place! And ain't I a woman?” (Truth) In this opening line of the speech, Truth reiterates that an anonymous man made claims about helping women, but that she hasn’t known such generosity in her life because she is a black woman.  She tells a story of how she had been told that women are deserving of a certain respect, when she herself had not been granted that same respect, because she was black and a former slave.  This was very common in her era.  While slavery was legally outlawed, it was still the default state of thinking for the average white male, who increasingly looked past black people, rather than treat them as equal citizens under the law. 
“Then that little man in black there, he says women can't have as much rights as men, 'cause Christ wasn't a woman! Where did your Christ come from? Where did your Christ come from? From God and a woman! Man had nothing to do with Him,” Truth reiterates later in her speech. This statement was directly aimed at the men in the audience who were vocally opposed to equal rights for women, believing that women were not able to logically handle important tasks like voting, or owning property because of their gender. This was a common opinion of the era, and women like Truth and her contemporaries railed hard against this opinion.
The Women’s Rights Conventions were large events, that were held until the Civil War.  They were so popular that people were often turned away due to size restraints of the space where they were held (Eisenberg) However, it would take another 61 years for women to gain the right to vote, and almost 100 years for black women to be afforded the same opportunities as their white counterparts.  If only Sojourner Truth had lived to see the fruits of her labor.




References
Butler, Mary G. “Sojourner Truth: A Life and Legacy of Faith” The Sojourner Truth Institute of Battle Creek, (date unknown) http://www.sojournertruth.org/library/archive/LegacyOfFaith.htm
Eisenberg, Bonnie and Ruthsdotter, Mary. “History of the Women’s Rights Movement” The National Women’s History Project. 1998, http://www.nwhp.org/resources/womens-rights-movement/history-of-the-womens-rights-movement/
Library of Congress Help Desk “African American Odyssey: Sojourner Truth.” Library of Congress, 09 December 1998, http://www.loc.gov/exhibits/odyssey/educate/truth.html
Michals, Debra. “Sojourner Truth (1797 – 1883).” National Women’s History Museum, 2015, https://www.womenshistory.org/education-resources/biographies/sojourner-truth
Truth, Sojourner. “Ain’t I a Woman?” Women’s Convention, Akron, Ohio. 1851
“Sojourner’s Words and Music” Sojourner Truth Memorial Committee, (date unknown)



-------------------------
Grade: 75/100
Professor Comments: None

No comments:

Post a Comment